Home Automation is all about establishing a level of ‘control’ in the home for the benefit of the people who live there.  The level your home is at right now depends on two factors –

  1. your perception of needing to control, and
  2. the amount of automation in operation.

Through experience, research and in consideration of these two factors I’ve defined a seven level model.

Level Perception Automation
1 Unaware None
2 Aware Manual
3 Aware Remote
4 Aware Programmed
5 Aware Triggered
6 Aware Learning
7 Unaware Intelligent

Here in St Albans, our house is working towards level 5.  What does that really mean? Let’s take a look at each of these levels in more detail.

Level 1 – Unaware, None

TentIt’s important to include this definition in the model for completeness – we have to start somewhere!

I would imagine that very few, if any, homes in the UK are at Level 1.  There is no perceived need to control any function of the dwelling – manually or otherwise.  If you consider this further, perhaps a very basic tent may be a candidate – no running water, no electricity, no windows or doors – literally nothing that would need controlling.

Level 2 – Aware, Manual

Cast your mind back to your Nan’s house in the late 1970’s!  This is a classic Level 2 dwelling.  We’ve got all the mod-cons of the era – TV, Radio, Washing Machine, Oven, Hi-Fi (with stupidly huge speakers ’cause your Grandad loved the great sound quality) – and all the usual items that make up the property itself – doors, windows, lighting, locks, etc, etc.

You’re Nan was aware that everything needed to be turned on or off as and when the need arose.  The reason their generation was so thin and fit was because whenever they wanted to change the channel on the TV or open a window they had to stand up and do it themselves.

Level 3 – Aware, Remote

TV RemoteAs the 1970’s rolled in to the 1980’s the ‘TV Clicker’ or ‘TV Remote Control’ first entered the UK mainstream.   The most common form of automation that exists in almost every home in the UK today is your ‘TV Remote’.  It’s a simple way to change the volume, channel or play your favourite recording without having to get up from the chair.  It’s perhaps an over simplified example – but you get the idea.

The level to which one chooses to introduce remote control to the home is a very personal decision.  Moving on from the TV example, simply adding a remote control to turn on the lights in your front room is the next step.  And so it accelerates – turning on lights, opening garage doors, adjusting window blinds, closing curtains, turning on heating, watering gardens, etc, etc.  In fact, wherever there is a button in the home that acts as an on/off or dimmer switch, you can add a ‘remote control’ function to it.

But that’s not really automation – it’s just putting in a remote switch.  There is no intelligence or pre-programmed schedule as to when to do something.

Level 4 – Aware, Programmed

Consider a scenario that requires our Kitchen lights to turn on just before Dark every night.  This is an easy task for someone in the home – but it’s surprising how much more information is needed to ‘automate’ this simple task.

A basic understanding of Home Automation is required from this point on.  If you’re unsure, click on the link to discover more before reading any further!

CalendarLevel 4 takes the basic Home Automation Hub and builds upon it by allowing the user to program a series of tasks to turn things on or off on a simple schedule.  As each Level builds upon the capability of the previous one, it’s important to highlight that Level 4 also has the capability to support ‘Remote Control’.  Rather than the ‘remote’ directly talking to the Appliance as in Level 3, the remote now communicates directly with the ‘Hub’ to send basic commands.

Remember our Kitchen lights?  Now, using the model we’ve created through a basic understanding of Level 4, we can program the Hub to turn the lights on every day at 5pm and turn them off again at 11pm after we’ve typically gone to bed.

This a great step forward, but in reality, not a very useful one.  There are too many ‘gotchas’ that will jump out to spoil the schedule – ever changing times of dusk through the year; dark and cloudy weather may require the lights to come on earlier; what if someone is in the room at 11pm when the lights turn off?  You get the idea.  And so on to Level 5.

Level 5 – Aware, Triggered

Let’s continue with the Kitchen light example.  We’ve already configured our light to turn on at a specific time of the day, but as the time of dusk changes constantly through the year, we need to sharp tune this to be more accurate.

We now need to take a close look at what sort of sensors might help us determine the most appropriate time to turn on the light.

shutterstock_186320450Weather – we can poll a personal or local Weather Station or a National Service to determine the current conditions outside.  We’re really interested to know if it’s cloudy.

Light – a typical motion sensor should come with multiple capabilities built in – motion (obviously), force, luminance and temperature are common.  Instead of using the Weather sensor, we could read the true amount of light to better understand how dark it is in the Kitchen.

Location – knowing where we are on the planet will help us determine the time of ‘dusk’.  Some Hubs will have this time value already calculated by default.

Bringing these three sensors together, we can create a trigger that can turn the light on when the light level in the room drops too far or when we ‘know’ it’s dusk outside.  This is, of course, a very simple example.

Using the combination of sensors and appliances, coupled with events and triggers, we can quickly build a wide array of actions that really bring the house to life.

  • If it’s not rained for two days and it’s summer, water the garden
  • If you’re getting closer to home and it’s a bit cold, turn on the heating
  • If you receive an e-mail, play a sound around the house
  • If you’re away from home for more than 24 hours, set the alarm
  • If there is motion detected on an outside camera, send a text to my phone
  • If this, then that … a great resource for more ideas

Our house is now starting to really come alive.  It can operate a programmed schedule of activities and can respond to events outside and around the house to give a far greater sense of automation.  However, everything that the house is doing has been previously ‘configured’ (at best) or ‘coded’ (at worst) and has likely taken a long time to really bring to life.

Level 6 – Aware, Learning

This is the current ‘cliff face’ of Home Automation.  Our previous example of the Kitchen Light has to be left behind as we venture ahead to Level 6.  Instead, I’m going to take a real life example of the Nest Thermostat – a modular heating control that has been developed to connect your home’s boiler to the world of automation.

Nest is a small company with big ideas.  Big enough that Google bought the company a couple of years ago.  They have three products in their range – Thermostat, Smoke Alarm and Camera.  They are capable of communicating with one another via a ‘mesh’ network called ‘Nest Weave‘.  Similar to Apple’s HomeKit, the Weave network is being rolled out to other third party companies who are eager for their devices to be included.  This is a great step forward for the Internet of Things although I’m left wondering if we’re looking at another VHS vs BetaMax – only time will tell.

nest-stock-image-1At Level 5, the Nest Thermostat was capable of sensing how warm your house was, knowing how far away from home you were, and starting a heating cycle at the right time so your home was just the right temperature when you arrived home.  It lights up when you walk past it.  If coupled with the Nest Smoke Alarm, should smoke or CO2 be detected, the Thermostat could turn off your boiler.  It’s even got a mobile App!

With Level 6, we start to see additional features of the Thermostat come to life.  It ‘learns’ how long it takes to warm your house from a particular starting temperature and the difference between a sunny and cloudy day.  It starts to remember what time you usually come home and can understand when you are away for a prolonged period.  It builds a schedule based on when you turn down the heat before bed and starts to automatically adjust the temperature based on this schedule.

It’s a great device.  But I don’t own one – and neither will I.  Not because I don’t love it – I do – but simply because it doesn’t go far enough in terms of it’s reach.  It controls the heating centrally, where as, at least in our house, we control the heating room by room using Radiator Thermostats.  It turns off the boiler in an emergency, but doesn’t stop the flow of gas.  With the release and adoption of Weave, these may just be gaps that are soon to be filled … only time will tell.

Reflecting on the concept, the idea of a ‘learning’ device is really one that records state changes from multiple sensors and has a set of pre-programmed actions that are activated upon certain conditions being met.  It’s not really learning in the true sense, but from the outside looking in, it certainly appears that way.

As we move forward I believe we will see significant growth in the way in which our devices and appliances learn more about how we like to use them.  It opens up another level of opportunities for the automated home and for the manufacturers to learn more about how we use their products.  It’s also key if we are to ever reach the pinnacle of our ascent.

Level 7 – Unaware, Intelligent

In a nutshell, we’re not here yet!  In truth, we’re a long way off.  So far off, it’s difficult for us to predict exactly what this would look like.

Intelligence is more than knowledge – it’s a huge leap from the ‘Learning’ capabilities we discussed in Level 6.  It’s about taking the built-up knowledge, applying common sense and reasoning to any decision and monitoring the reaction of those with whom it’s engaged.

shutterstock_221369392My sense is that the fully automated home of the future will be so connected to everything, so aware of it’s environment, so understanding of it’s occupant’s needs – that it will be akin to a living, breathing organism.  In this state, I doubt we would be aware of the need to control anything – it would all be predicted and managed for us without concern or consideration.

Too far?  Perhaps.

As a home automation enthusiast, I can’t imagine anything worse.  As I consider my own personal walk – taking our own home from Level 3 to Level 5 – I’ve come to understand that it’s been the journey itself, rather than the destination, that has fanned those automation flames and brought me so much enjoyment over recent years.

How boring it would be to have the home do all the hard work; for it to never go wrong.  Come to think of it, I’d probably move out!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s